Summary
Users express dissatisfaction with current fitness apps due to a lack of personalization, poor organization, repetitive content, and difficulties in maintaining motivation. Many apps are perceived as stale, with features that are not intuitive or cater to specific needs. There's a strong demand for more customization, better UI/UX, varied workout options, and improved data syncing, especially for those with limited access to equipment or budgets.

Actions

Start a new search
1
Lack of Customization & Personalization

Users want more personalized workout plans and customization options.

Users desire fitness apps that offer greater personalization in workout plans, allowing for exercise customization, the exclusion of certain movements, and the ability to alternate routines.

Quotes

Are there any that allow you to mark exercises to always be kept out of the plan? ie I can’t do RDL or any DL due to a back injury and I am interested in one that would let me substitute the exercise I can’t do with an alternate exercise or let me plug in my injuries from the get go and it’ll adjust for me?

I don't know if that app features this but I'd like to see a feature where you can make workout A and workout B and have it alternate on its own throughout the week. Kind of how strong lifts does it in their app. Most I've seen let you make a weekly workout routine but many routines change each week like Strong Lifts, SS, GSLP and it's variants and so on.

I don't know if that app features this but I'd like to see a feature where you can make workout A and workout B and have it alternate on its own throughout the week. Kind of how strong lifts does it in their app. Most I've seen let you make a weekly workout routine but many routines change each week like Strong Lifts, SS, GSLP and it's variants and so on.

I'd enjoy new badges/awards, whether those are things like awards for more workouts (First Boxing Workout, First Badminton Workout, etc), more limited edition challenges, or others (such as first half marathon, first marathon, etc). Or things like 50th XXX (Run, Swim, etc) workout, 25 different workouts recorded, etc.

I’m looking for something to create a workout routine, also I very much made it clear in my post that I have no access to equipment, I’m a complete beginner, so i don’t know the first thing to creating a routine

I use Fitbod for tracking strength and peloton for everything else. I'd recommend Peloton's Strength+ if you have an iPhone so everything is tracked together (sadly I'm on Android)

I use Fitbod for weight training, but a year subscription nets out to $5 a month. It changes up your muscle groups depending on what you recently did, and you can set your equipment and workout time. I prefer to just put my head down and work when at the gym, and this is the perfect app for that.

Frequency7
Intensity7
Specificity8
Solvability8
2
App Organization and Usability

Difficulty navigating and finding specific content within fitness apps.

Users struggle with poorly organized app interfaces, lack of filtering options, and the absence of features like playlists or folders, making it hard to find desired workouts.

Quotes

But that always seems very obvious to me anyway when I look at the workouts flagged as “new” each Monday. I always like to do a Mindful Cooldown at the end of my strength and core workouts three times a week but can see they’re only adding one Mindful Cooldown workout a week now so I’m going to run out in the next 5-6 weeks (probably less as I can’t stand doing any workouts with Molly!)

Also, why is the 'library' at the bottom? Wouldn't I want classes I bookmarked toward the top? Not after every other little thing they want to suggest. The Library is almost useless anyway as there is no way to filter or sort it. Apple is usually so go at making things intuitive. I cannot understand why this was so badly set up.

I just want playlists/folders 😭

It’s just not intuitive. They need a better sort and filters function.

The Nike Training Club is so minimalist and easy to navigate. But I like the variety of AF+! apple needs to step up, oof.

Viewing workouts in the fitness app is poor and your only option to get anything meaningful is to use 3rd party apps.

It’s terrible. It is so cluttered and the filters are awful and why on earth is there no way to make customized playlists?

Frequency7
Intensity7
Specificity8
Solvability7
3
Lack of Motivation and Engagement

Difficulty maintaining motivation and consistent engagement with fitness apps.

Users find it challenging to stay motivated with fitness apps, citing unengaging challenges, a lack of desired rewards (like badges), and a general difficulty in maintaining consistent use over time.

Quotes

The challenges are lame at best. They used to be very hard to get some months. I think this was because they wanted to be more inclusive to non exercisers. Too bad they don’t have different tiers of challenges for people who want to really push themselves and separate from the pack.

I wish there were more special challenges/badges, and I wish it was more motivating for getting those. I was a Fitbit user before Apple Watch and loved all their random badges. You got just enough for it to be motivating but it wasn’t oversaturated

Fitness Motivation: This one was fitness specific. We failed early on to give people a reason "Why" for using our app. Particularly because motivating someone to exercise is a very difficult problem.

So I’ve used multiple workout apps and all were scams I don’t understand why they are the only way I’ll stay consistent but they are I have no equipment nor the money for it, I’m in school so my schedule is tight, and no matter how much I try to go to the gym I just can’t do anything because my mind is too focused on the people around me

I was getting so discouraged by the numbers on the scale bouncing around, and Happy Scale helps me visualize trends and not get bummed/demotivated when things don’t move the way I might like them to.

Fitness apps are a hard market to create staying power in my experience. What happens for me is that I will gain a lot of motivation and want to track this and that so I’ll download an app to help. Then I find my routine by using it and it’s going well - and I realize I no longer need the app, I’m comfortable just eyeballing what I’m doing, or at the most using a notebook to track my numbers to improve. The cycle continues like this or I never pick up an app again due to casually exercising.

Frequency6
Intensity7
Specificity8
Solvability6
4
Repetitive Content and Features

Fitness apps offer stale or repetitive workouts and features.

Users are experiencing staleness and repetition in fitness app content, including goals, challenges, and specific workout types, leading to a desire for more variety and updates.

Quotes

Anyone else feel the fitness app has gotten stale? The goals, rings, awards, same thing for so many years. I know some people haven’t had the Apple Watch as long as others but for the people that have since day one do you find it’s time for some sort of refresh?

I like it as my accountability buddy but it has gotten repetitive

Not necessarily the app But I’m tired of the Fitness+ rowing workouts. Same room. Same people. For years. Mix it up a little - maybe get them outside in the water for a change

This. My challenges were repetitive and too easy.

Part of me thinks this is because if you've been a subscriber since the early days and you've done a lot of the workouts like I have, filtering would result in us seeing just how few new workouts there are.

Frequency5
Intensity6
Specificity7
Solvability7
5
Data Syncing and Integration Issues

Problems with fitness apps not syncing data correctly with wearables.

Users encounter significant frustration when fitness apps fail to sync workout data accurately with their wearable devices, leading to lost progress and the need to repeat workouts.

Quotes

Secondly, the apps syncing with the apple watch is kind of horrible. I completed a 26 minute workout, and it didn’t even save the data. Now I have to complete the same workout over again. Just so it will show up on my progress.

I'd say major refresh.. Tracking exercise has improved loads via apple watch, the watch fitness app has improved but the phone app is only marginally better. Viewing workouts in the fitness app is poor and your only option to get anything meaningful is to use 3rd party apps.

I tried apple fitness. Not a fan, especially since I couldn't stream on my TV.

Frequency3
Intensity7
Specificity7
Solvability5
6
Lack of Equipment/Accessibility

Workout apps often require equipment that users cannot afford or access.

Many users, particularly students or those with limited finances, struggle to find workout apps that cater to their lack of access to gym equipment or personal workout gear.

Quotes

I have no equipment nor the money for it, I’m in school so my schedule is tight, and no matter how much I try to go to the gym I just can’t do anything because my mind is too focused on the people around me Every workout video ever requires some sort of equipment that I can’t afford My best option is a workout app but they all seem to be scams

sadly, cant find a single think on boostcamp that doesn’t require equipment

I specifically don’t have access to equipment

Frequency3
Intensity8
Specificity9
Solvability9
7
Cost and Subscription Overwhelm

Overwhelmed by the number of fitness apps and their associated costs.

Users feel overwhelmed by the sheer number of fitness apps available and the associated subscription costs, making it difficult to choose and justify paying for them.

Quotes

Wait what? How is it only $12 for you? I think I’m paying $40/month 🧐

With so many fitness apps on the market, it's hard to really choose one and believe the reviews, and so on.

Then comes the fact that the second they add stuff like recovery… why would I pay a scammy $30 a month to whoop (no shade to whoop, but it’s unnecessarily expensive for what it is and realistically the worst value tracker imo)

Frequency3
Intensity6
Specificity7
Solvability7
8
Poor User Interface (UI) Design

Fitness apps often have poor UI design, making them unappealing or difficult to use.

Some users find fitness apps to have unappealing or poorly executed UI designs, citing issues with fonts, button placement, and overall visual presentation.

Quotes

Your app is facing the problem which every health app faces in its initial stages, what you have to do here is to get to know your customers very well and understand what their pain points are, you can refer the blog: http://www.sparkbehavior.com/2013/11/6-reasons-fitness-apps-fail/

Sorry to say but your app doesn't look visually appealing to me UI wise. Things like title being too long and getting clipped, black status bar on dark background, extremely thin fonts, square buttons instead of rounded corners, light colored text over white background etc. People need visual candy from software!

Frequency2
Intensity6
Specificity8
Solvability5
9
Limited Workout Variety

Desire for more diverse workout options within fitness apps.

Users are looking for fitness apps to include a wider range of workout types, such as mountain biking, to cater to diverse fitness interests.

Quotes

I'd just like them to add mountain biking as a workout option

Frequency1
Intensity5
Specificity6
Solvability7

Actions

Start a new search

Stop Wasting Days on Manual
Market Research

Get comprehensive market research, competitor analysis, and customer insights in minutes instead of days. ProblemTotem analyzes thousands of real Reddit conversations to uncover what your audience actually needs.

Start your research